Search
  • ethanmudavanhu

EndCoders Attending: SAHRC Workshop On 4IR And Human Rights

On the 5– 6 March, the South African Human Rights Commission (SAHRC) hosted a workshop on 4IR and Human Rights in Johannesburg.


The SAHRC is a Chapter 9 institution mandated by the Constitution to raise awareness of human rights issues; monitor and assess the observance of human rights; educate and train on human rights; address human rights violations and seek effective redress. Pursuant to that mandate, the Workshop sought to initiate conversation over 4IR and how it could impact human rights in South Africa.


Given the controversy on how hate speech is regulated in South Africa, the discussion on Internet Rights and Responsibilities: Freedom of Expression and Hate Speech was fascinating. Considering how controversial the narrative around hate speech is, how can we regulate it?


Samkelo Mokhine (Executive Director at Freedom of Expression Institute) discussed social media platforms (Facebook in particular). He emphasized the dire need for these companies to consult stating this is “…not just tick-box consultation but meaningful consultation/engagement with stakeholders on what they find offensive.” He further opined that if they cannot be trusted to take this initiative themselves, that perhaps they should be forced through regulation.


Mokhine also addressed consent fatigue and candidly admitted to not reading the “fine-print” when it comes to rights and responsibilities of users before signing into some of these platforms. He was of the view that this too must be sent back to the companies to fix. His suggestion was that terms of use should be clear, shorter, presented in local languages and accompanied by videos that explain the implications. Finally, he emphasised the need for “these companies to reflect our African values e.g. respect.”


Another fascinating speaker was Wiliam Bird (Director of Media Monitoring Africa) who discussed how our approach to 4IR should be seeded in human rights. Bird is of the view that one way to achieve this is to prioritize critical learning and digital literacy skills. His research show that the only people that are/can benefit from 4IR are those who grew up with technology (i.e. those with money).


According to Bird, digital literacy is the most essential method fork.r fighting the issue of ‘fake news’ (disinformation in general seemed to be a hot topic). He attempted to discredit the notion of regulating hate speech because of when we are regulate, we are merely adopt global frameworks that do not necessarily work in Africa i.e. without context, the term ‘hate speech’ itself is difficult to define and government cannot be tasked to define it, given the nature and speed of the internet.


He concluded by arguing that the solution is co-regulation. He offered the Press Council as an example of how co-regulation could work.

EndCode HQ

35 Ballyclare Drive

Ballyoaks Office Park

Silky Oak House   

Bryanston, Sandton 

South Africa

base@endcode.org +27 (0) 11 463 4594 | Reg No. 2014/ 118528/07